Fixed Income Analytics: Optimizing Convexity Risk
Thursday, August 16th, 2012In today’s market environment, several key factors exist that serve to make the effect of convexity on a MBS
portfolio especially pronounced. This article will briefly review two principal issues that mortgage portfolio
managers are currently focused on – volatility in the US Treasury market and options for hedging – together with
the corresponding impact on fixed income analytic systems (such as Yield Book, POINT or Blackrock).
MARKET VOLATILITY First, the USD Treasury market presently illustrates a level of volatility consistent
with historical, non-crisis highs. As the current pricing of implied volatility for a basket of at-the-money options on
liquid, benchmark off-the-run Treasuries demonstrates, the bond market is clearly communicating expectations for
continued high volatility in the near & intermediate term. As various pieces of positive global macroeconomic news
are unveiled, and investors consider the asymmetrical risk associated with a 2.50% 30-year UST, the potential for a
sharp V-shaped move higher in US interest rates remains only a catalyst (or two) away.
With mortgage portfolios, however, rising rates introduces a self-feeding reinforcement mechanism as PMs sell
duration (principally via USTs and interest rate swaps) to hedge the portfolio lengthening impact of convexity,
which causes rates to go higher which causes PMs to sell more duration and so forth. This increases both the
severity and speed of a rate environment adjustment due to every mortgage PM having the same predictable
problem. Due to the enormous growth in the size of the MBS market over the past decade, the hedging
requirements (on an absolute basis) are commensurate and issues with liquidity in certain Treasury instruments
quickly emerge. These yield short-term pricing distortions unquestionably result in a higher cost of convexity
hedging which can act as a material drag on overall portfolio performance.
RISING RATES Second, significant uncertainty exists coming from the unprecedented record prolonged low
nominal mortgage rates.. It is simply unknown how sharply prepays will fall if (or, perhaps more aptly, when)
rates revert to their long-term “normalized” trend line which exist in the stratosphere somewhere perhaps ~200
to 300 bp above current levels of a 1.50% 10-year UST. While research resources at firms such as Citi (Yield
Book) and Barclay’s (POINT) have no doubt been working diligently to model the impact of rates experiencing
a lasting regression to the mean, the absence of historical experience or analyzable data makes this ultimately an
academic exercise. With refi activity encompassing almost 80% of the MBA’s Market Composite Index, however,
it unquestionably will have a generational influence on the mortgage market. Mortgage investors everywhere will
feel this uncertainty, volatility and potential lack of reliability with existing prepayment models, and with particular
emphasis on those mortgage instruments that exhibit outsized dynamic price behavior with even modest changes in
market parameters.
IMPACT ON APPLICATIONS Let’s now transition to the impact of these factors on a buy-side firm’s
fixed income analytic platform. While the process for accommodating prepayment assumptions on a bond-
level basis almost certainly exists for pricing within any batch processing structure, the uncertainty surrounding
the performance of existing prepayment models has no doubt put MBS traders, quants and PMs in a position of
needing to potentially make substantial changes to the speeds at which various MBS instruments are priced. Buy-
side firms with a substantial exposure to MBS will need to review the process by which prepayment assumptions
for pricing are generated (such as through a IO/PO Breakeven model, for example) and consider structural reform,
if necessary. Furthermore, a pertinent, logical question remains as to how all of these moving parts will affect
mortgage benchmark duration. For the FI Applications Manager, now is the time to be evaluating and enhancing
existing processes, not once the market fireworks have begun.
Secondly, the recent volatility witnessed in both global Treasury rates and risk spreads communicates quite clearly
to the Head of Analytics (or FI Financial Engineering / FI Technology) at every buy-side firm the absolutely
critical nature of ensuring that any problem with processes associated with Yield Book, Blackrock and POINT
be proactively addressed by support staff. In an environment where 10 to 20+ basis point shifts in benchmark
US Treasury rates can be repeatedly seen on a daily basis, it is simply unacceptable to front office FI resources
to be asked to rely on day-old data – or data available at 11:00 a.m. – should any vital production process break
down. The absence of current FI analytic data is one of the fastest ways to hamstring an organization’s trading and
portfolio management operations.
Left unresolved, these issues can end up costing a firm in several different critical ways. In a more volatile
investment environment, it becomes increasingly difficult to rely on day-old data should problems occur which
result in traders, portfolio managers and analysts needing to spend valuable time manually calculating current-day
values prior to taking action. Additionally, with the expected variability and uncertainty in prepayment model cash
flow projections, not having a sufficiently developed process for generating daily prepayment-speeds for MBS
holdings could result in poor portfolio performance, inaccurate risk forecasts and duration mismatch between
portfolio and benchmark. Put together, both of these problems can have material negative impacts – both explicit
and implicit – that justify the economics of allocating resources towards taking proactive steps to resolve them.
HOW ADEPTYX CAN HELP At Adeptyx, our Fixed Income Analytics Consulting practice offers expertise
in both of these crucial areas: DEVELOPMENT and SUPPORT. Whether your needs encompass updating your
existing Fixed Income Analytic infrastructure to address the types of issues outlined above – or simply ensuring
that your POINT, Blackrock or Yield Book setup delivers reliable, consistent results every night of the week – we
have the unique resources to solve your most complex and challenging problems. Our Fixed Income Analytics
Consulting practice brings highly experienced, hard-to-find skill sets bringing together expertise in:
- Understanding esoteric bond structures and analytic / risk calculations
- Conceptualizing how FI analytic applications such as Yield Book / POINT / Blackrock interact with
other fundamental systems such as accounting, trade order management, client reporting and performance
attribution - Enabling communication between FI Technology and Trading / Research / Portfolio Management / Risk
Contact Mark Bredesen (markbredesen (at) adeptyx.com) or Ari Fuad (arifuad (at) adeptyx.com) to begin a collaborative
discussion on how Adeptyx can benefit your firm.
